Public Bridleway Dispute

A recent case in Little Berkhamsted, Hertfordshire, underscores the complexities and financial burdens associated with boundary disputes. Dr. Dawn Carnell and her husband, David Moore, purchased their property in 2015, unaware that a public bridleway traversed their land. In 2019, they removed right-of-way signs and locked the gates, restricting access to a path historically used by locals for over a century. This action ignited a legal battle with neighbors, each side incurring substantial legal fees—£50,000 for the neighbors seeking easements and £250,000 for Carnell and Moore defending their position.

Despite their claims that the bridleway's existence was unclear due to mapping discrepancies between 1924 and 1957, Hertfordshire County Council upheld the bridleway's legitimacy, stating it was "inconceivable" the couple was unaware of its presence. 

This dispute highlights the importance of thorough due diligence when purchasing property and the potential consequences of altering or obstructing established rights of way. Boundary disputes can be both emotionally and financially draining. Early legal consultation is essential to navigate these complex issues effectively.

For advice on boundaries and rights of way, please contact Oliver Kew

Published on 19/03/2025