Can One Person in a Joint Tenancy Unilaterally Determine The Tenancy?

The case of Dacorum Borough Council v Sims centred around whether the long-standing rule that one party to a joint tenancy can unilaterally determine the tenancy, can withstand a human rights challenge under art 8 (respect for home) and art 1 (deprivation of property rights) of the First Protocol.

-    A joint tenancy effectively gives all tenants exactly equal rights over the property.
-    Article 8 provides a qualified right to respect for the home.
-    Article 1 of the First Protocol provides a qualified right to freedom from state interference with possessions (which can include an agreement for a tenancy of residential property).

In this case, Mr Sims argued that the rule which had enabled his wife to end the joint tenancy of their home without any recourse to him was incompatible with his rights under both articles.

The Court of Appeal disagreed with Mr Sims, deciding neither article was engaged by the operation of the rule.

-    Firstly, Mr Sims’ right to occupy his home had, to his own knowledge, always been qualified by the right for either him or his wife to end their tenancy by serving the council with notice to quit. The exercise of that right by Mrs Sims couldn’t, therefore, amount to an ‘interference’ within the meaning of either art 8 or art 1 of the First Protocol.
-    Secondly, the serving of the notice wasn’t the act of a public authority, to whom the articles apply.

Mr Sims may yet apply to the Supreme Court for permission to appeal, or take his case to the European Court of Human Rights.

 

Oliver Kew

Published on 07/02/2013

Hewetts News

11/09/2018: Why workers’ rights will remain unchanged in a no deal Brexit

(or, for what it’s worth, in a Brexit deal). Read +

24/05/2018: New Online Divorce Service

With effect from 1st May 2018 the Ministry of Justice has made a new online service available to the public for the filing of divorce papers Read +

More News...

Request a Callback

×

Please provide the following information and we'll arrange for one of our solicitors to give you a call-back within the next 2 working days.